The Matrix and Plato's excerpt " The Allegory of The Cave," both try to explain the process of giving up illusions and embracing truth. I believe The Matrix was more accurate and realistic. Neo was given a choice to know the truth or to keep living the life he was used to. Also, the truth is ugly and lies are comfortable. There was even a person who wanted to go back to living an illusion, just like in real life. "The Allegory of The Cave," was good at trying to explain the process of giving up illusions but The Matrix did a better job.
First, Neo was given a choice to know the truth or to keep living the life he was used to. The red and blue pills symbolized the options he had on the table. In life, all we have is options but it's up to you to decide which ones you want to embrace. Some people choose to live in a bubble and remain ignorant. For example, when you start to talk to a religious person about evolution, they simply take the blue pill and go on with their life in their illusion. Neo took the red pill and wanted to know the truth. Morpheus gave him the option to know or not to know and in real life, that is how it usually happens. In "The Allegory of The Cave," the person had noone to give him a choice, but in reality you always need help. It could be help from a teacher, videos, ect. You don't just get a light bulb and realize the truth, you must have sources and choices.
Second, in process of giving up illusions, the truth is ugly and the lies are comfortable. In "The Allegory of The Cave," the world outside of the cave is better but in reality that is rarely the case. On the other hand in The Matrix, the real world was a dystopian world. People always want to believe the illusion to remain comfortable. Noone wants to hear about people starving around the world, so they don't even think about it and ignore reality. I remember I was trying to explain to my friend that wars are fought just to make profit. He didn't want to believe the truth and wanted to believe the illusion given to him by the news. He thinks wars are to protect the people but it really just is for oil, selling weapons, power, and most important money. The truth is unpleasant and when you leave the cave it won't show you a wonderful world, it really just is a dystopia.
Third, there is always people who want to go back to living the illusion after learning the truth. In The Matrix it was a man named Cipher. He was tired of knowing the truth and was willing to do whatever to go back to the illusion. Neo also felt he wanted to go back to his illusion after he was overwhelmed by the truth. People usually have a hard time accepting the truth. My friend went to Japan to help the people rebuild but when he saw so many dead people he ran right back to the U.S. He saw the truth with his eyes and it hurt him so much he ran back to his illusion of a perfect life in the U.S. People are sometimes weak and not strong enough to face reality. In "The Allegory of The Cave," the person only was hurt for a while and overcame it, but in real life some people run right back to the cave forever to avoid anything that hurts them. Another example, a person who doesn't believe in God starts to believe the illusion when a family member dies because they turn weak from the hurt. They rather believe they'll see the person in heaven than to accept that they'll never see eachother again, it's because lies are comfortable and the truth is very ugly.
The process of giving up illusions and embracing the truth is a very complex one. I believe The Matrix did a better job than Plato's excerpt "The Allegory of The Cave," in trying to explain this process. Neo was given a choice to know or not to know. Neo entered an ugly reality when he found out the truth, because the truth is ugly and lies are comfortable. In The Matrix, there were people who wanted to go back to living an illusion. The Matrix was more accurate on the process humans go through to leave a lie and to embrace the truth.
Sincerely, Kevin Cortes
Blog #10
12 years ago